SEC FAQ Update Clarifies Broker Custody for Bitcoin ETPs

  • The SEC updated its Trading and Markets FAQs on Dec. 17, 2025, clarifying how broker-dealers can establish 'control' of crypto-asset securities under Rule 15c3-3(c).
  • SEC staff said it would not object to treating proprietary bitcoin inventory used in in-kind ETP creations and redemptions as 'readily marketable' with a 20% commodity haircut for net capital.
  • The SEC withdrew the 2019 SEC/FINRA joint staff statement on broker-dealer custody of digital asset securities, elevating the FAQ framework as the main reference.
SEC FAQ Update Clarifies Broker Custody for Bitcoin ETPs
Image Source

The SEC updated its Trading and Markets staff FAQs on Dec. 17, 2025, detailing how broker-dealers can meet custody and capital requirements for crypto-asset securities, including activity tied to bitcoin and ether ETPs.

What the FAQ update changes

The SEC staff reiterated that Rule 15c3-3(b) “possession or control” does not apply to non-security bitcoin held by broker-dealers.

For crypto-asset securities, the staff said a broker-dealer can establish “control” under Rule 15c3-3(c) using qualifying control locations, even when an instrument is not certificated.

The staff also said this approach reduces reliance on the special-purpose broker-dealer (SPBD) safe harbor as the main route to demonstrate control.

Capital treatment for in-kind ETP activity

The SEC staff said it would not object if broker-dealers facilitating in-kind creations and redemptions treat proprietary positions in bitcoin or ether as “readily marketable” for net capital purposes.

That would apply the 20% commodity haircut under Rule 15c3-1 Appendix B.

Cryptoslate claims that a $50 million intraday inventory would imply about a $10 million net capital deduction under that haircut.

Prior guidance withdrawn

The SEC marked the 2019 SEC/FINRA joint staff statement on broker-dealer custody of digital asset securities as withdrawn, narrowing the framework to the updated FAQs.

The FAQ does not explicitly require broker-dealers to hold private keys, but “control” is tied to safeguarding and directing the movement of customer securities at a recognized control location.

The article noted the Federal Reserve withdrew earlier supervisory letters on April 24, 2025, changing advance-notice expectations for certain crypto-asset and dollar token activities.

Original Article